Adopt Me Pets: 19 Collectible Items Worth Keeping
If you’ve played Adopt Me for more than a few weeks, you’ve probably noticed how fast your inventory can fill up with random toys, vehicles, and seasonal gear. But hidden among all that clutter are collectible items that could become surprisingly valuable over time. As someone who’s spent countless hours organizing, trading, and comparing notes with other collectors, I’ve put together this list of 19 collectible items that are genuinely worth keeping — whether you’re into rare finds, hoping to trade up, or just curious about what makes certain items special.
1. Candy Cannon
Arguably one of the most iconic items in the game. Its ability to shoot candy makes it a party essential, and its rarity keeps demand high.
2. Tombstone Ghostify
This Halloween classic lets players turn invisible. It’s a favorite for roleplayers and consistently holds value among collectors.
3. Neon Ride Potion
While not every player keeps one, having a Neon Ride Potion in your collection can impress during trades, especially when paired with rare pets.
4. Fly Potion (from early releases)
Many players used their Fly Potions immediately, but keeping an original, unused potion can be surprisingly valuable to serious collectors.
5. Chinese Lantern
This beautiful light source is no longer available, and collectors love adding it to themed builds.
6. Marsh Plush
A fun plush toy from earlier updates that’s grown rare simply because so many were traded away.
7. Pumpkin Stroller
A seasonal stroller that always returns in conversations about Halloween-themed inventories.
8. Ghost Vehicle
Only available during specific events, this vehicle is both fun and relatively scarce.
9. Bunny Carriage
Part of an Easter event, this charming carriage fits perfectly into themed builds and seasonal trading.
10. Snowflake Potion
Seasonal items like this often see steady growth in trade value because they aren’t coming back.
11. Water Walking Potion
More unique than practical, but its novelty alone makes it a conversation piece in trades.
12. Rainbow Stroller
Bright, eye-catching, and discontinued — three traits collectors love.
13. Monkey King Staff
From the Monkey Fairground event, this decorative staff is still sought after by players building themed rooms.
14. Panda Pal Plush
Cute, rare, and especially popular among players looking for cheap adopt me pets add-ons.
15. Heart Hoverboard
Perfect for Valentine-themed houses or just cruising around with style.
16. Skele-Rex Plush
Another Halloween classic, and plush collectors are always looking for these retired items.
17. Elf Shrew
Not technically an item, but older event pets like this are highly collectible and worth holding onto instead of trading for quick gains.
18. Golden Rat
Released during the Lunar New Year event, and it remains a great mid-tier collectible.
19. Reindeer Plush
A cozy, seasonal plush that pops up in winter trades every year, often alongside adopt me pets for sale.
Why Keep Collectibles Instead of Trading Them?
Many players rush to trade away older event items to get cheap adopt me pets or quickly flip for something new. But if you can afford to hold onto these collectibles, they often appreciate in value far beyond what you’d get from a quick trade. Think of them as long-term investments in your Adopt Me journey.
Whether you’re playing casually or working to build the rarest inventory possible, keeping an eye on these collectible items can help you trade smarter — and show off a truly unique collection next time someone checks your inventory.